/
I'll be over in the other half of the world for a couple of weeks; blogging will be pretty-much out of the question. Heck, I'll be happy if I'm able to check email every coupla days.
Anyways, wish you all a very happy holiday season and a wonderful new year.
/
Tuesday, December 23, 2008
Hiatus
Sunday, December 21, 2008
Breaking the news: Sports edition
/
I had promised a data-backed piece on Eli Manning, so here goes. A couple of things I’d like to state before we proceed:
1) This is not a rant against Eli; it is against the so-called experts who write about him;
2) Eli is having a decent season, but it is laughable to call it a great, MVP-caliber, or even a Pro-Bowl-caliber season.
That having been said, let me mention, by way of example, some of the Eli-related journalistic plugs that have popped up in the past week or so. First, there’s this piece on how Eli finished 2nd in the MVP balloting amongst eight ESPN bloggers---these are the guys who cover the various NFL divisions and get paid by ESPN to write about them every week, so they are presumably experts. Well, their writings contribute to public opinion, at any rate. Then there’s this article by Sporting News’ NFL writer Vinnie Iyer where he puts Eli second in his NFC pro-bowl ballot---as a reward for Eli body of work---and I quote--- over the past two seasons, including the Super Bowl. Finally, there this Sporting News article naming Eli Manning SN’s Pro Athlete of the Year for 2008. Seriously. No, really. I cannot make this shit up.
Anyway, this is just an easily-obtained sampling of the general assessment of Eli Manning by many, if not most, sports reporters and analysts. As you can see from magazine articles (including the aforementioned ones) or hear on radio or TV (although my sampling size in the latter media is hardly extensive), there is this perception that Eli Manning was primarily responsible for the Giants’ Super Bowl run last year and for their continued success this year (he was, in a way, but not in the way you might think). Furthermore, there is this growing consensus that Eli is now an elite QB---one worthy of ProBowl selection and of MVP consideration. This idea is so absurd that I feel compelled to refute it. I realize that Eli is the QB of a historic franchise in arguably the biggest media market in the world and is also the scion of a famous quarterbacking clan. So there is an understandable urge in the media to hope for the Great All-American Family of Excellence Story. But the urge to fabricate that story around dubious facts?----Well, someone’s gotta smack that shit in the face with a fistful of reason. And in the apparent absence of any takers, I had to step up to be that someone.
So let us look at some numbers, shall we? (BTW, all the stats that I provide have been obtained from NFL.com and Pro-Football-Reference.com. For rankings, I referred to pages like this from NFL.com---so the rankings are for QBs who averaged at least 14 pass attempts per game, i.e. regulars. Also, 2008 numbers are through 14 games)
Since his first full year (in 2005) as starting QB for the NYGiants Eli Manning has been, by any measurable statistic, a mediocre QB. Here are his stats in all key categories.
| YEAR | COMPLETION%/ (NFL rank) | QB RATING/ (NFL rank) | TDs thrown/ (NFL Rank) | INTs thrown/ (NFL rank; 1st is worst) | |||
| 2005 | 52.8 (31st of 34) | 75.9 (23rd of 34) | 24 (7th of 34) | 17 (2nd of 34) | |||
| 2006 | 57.7 (21st of 32) | 77.0 (18th of 32) | 24 (6th of 32) | 18 (4th of 32) | |||
| 2007 | 56.1 (29th of 33) | 73.9 (25th of 33) | 23 (11th of 33) | 20 (1st of 33) | |||
| 2008 | 60.3 (19th of 32) | 86.4 (16th of 32) | 20 (10th of 32) | 10 (18th of 32) |
As you can see, the only category where Eli has ever cracked the top 5 is the one category where you DON’T want to be in the top as a QB---Interceptions thrown.
Note also that 2008 is Eli’s best year by far---when his overall QB rating has soared to a dizzying, career-best, 16th of 32 ranked QBs! I mean, talk about fucking mediocre!
What many people have chosen to forget about Eli is that not only did he throw more INTs than most but he threw crippling INTs. Not that there are good INTs but, you know, some are just worse than others. Anyway, in 2007 the Giants defense ranked 7th in the league for fewest yards allowed but only ranked 17th in the league for fewest points allowed. When a D allows a far greater proportion of points than would be predicted by the allowed yards, it implies that the opposition is the beneficiary of good field position. When you consistently give up good field position to the opposition, you either have horrible special teams or you have a serious turnover problem. Not surprisingly the Giants ranked a bad 26th of 32 teams in the takeaway/giveaway ratio in 2007 ---Eli ranked 1st in most INTs thrown, the offense lost 14 of 26 fumbles, and while it isn‘t clear how many of those were Eli‘s, the stats do show that Eli was responsible for 13 of the team‘s 26 fumbles.
By comparison in 2008, the Giants D ranks 6th in the league in fewest yards allowed (similar to 2007) and 4th in fewest points allowed (a bit different from 2007, eh?). Not coincidentally, Eli has only thrown 10 INTs, the offense has lost only 3 fumbles all year and the Giants rank 3rd best in the league in the Takeaway/Giveaway ratio. More significantly, while the Giants passing game is producing about the same yards (210.2 yds/game in 2008 vs. 211 yds/game in 2007) and their running game is producing somewhat better (148.7 yds/game in 2008 vs. 134.3 yds/game in 2007), the Giants offense ranks 4th in the league in total points and 8th in total yards in 2008 compared to 14th in total points and 16th in total yards in 2007.
(Giants 2007 stats here, and 2008 stats here)
Amazing what happens when you don’t turn the ball over huh? And that, in a nutshell, is why Eli is getting all the love. It’s not that he’s raised his QBing to great heights a la Montana or Marino or even his own brother Peyton. Eli finally stopped fucking up!
And that was basically why the Giants succeeded in their playoff run last year---Eli didn’t have significantly better numbers in the 2007 postseason than he did before; he had basically the same mediocre numbers. In the 2007 postseason Eli completed 60.5% of his passes, threw for 213.5 yards/game, and averaged 1.5 TDs thrown per game. But herre's the key stat---he threw only one INT in four games. This is doubtless creditable, but it is hardly great. The Giants win in the Super Bowl was due primarily to its ferocious defense that physically dominated the game. They held the highest-scoring offense in NFL history to 14 points. Yes, Eli did lead a drive in the end to give the Giants the lead, but that was not a high-efficiency surgical drive that is the stuff of Montana legend. Indeed, the signature play in that drive was an incredible, once-in-a-lifetime catch by David Tyree that answered an Eli Manning Hail Mary prayer. Eli wasn’t without credit in the postseason and the SuperBowl, but the Super Bowl MVPs were, in order, the Giants D-line, David Tyree, and then Eli.
But for whatever reason, the bar for Eli is low when it comes to most in the media. For him apparently, not fucking up equals greatness.
One last thing---people come up with arguments like the “Stats aren’t everything, there are intangibles to the QB position”. To them I present QBs who have far fewer weapons at their disposal than Eli but have lead their teams to impressive success with modest individual stats (although these guys do have better overall ratings than Eli!), but who yet do not get as much pub and accolades as Eli does. Qbs like Matt Ryan---a rookie who stepped into a horrendous situation in Atlanta and has them at an impressive winning record while playing in an NFC South division where no team has a losing record--- and Chad Pennington, who stepped into an equally horrible situation in Miami and has them contending for the lead in their division.
I could go on---with examples and with stats. But I’ll stop here. Eli may yet turn into a great QB. But in his career thus far he has done nothing extraordinary. He has been surrounded by a great team with pro-bowl talent at every offensive position. He finally stopped holding his team back.
But hey, if and when Eli ever makes the top five in QB rating for the year, the media will probably be clamoring for him to be first-ballot Hall-of-Famer.
/
Thursday, December 18, 2008
Bad move, President-elect Obama
/
It is not a cabinet appointment or anything like that, merely a symbolic selection. But by picking a bigoted asshole like Rick Warren to deliver the invocation at the Inaugural, the Obama camp has made a very important (and dangerous) concession to tens of millions of subscribers of organized religious wackaloonery. Apparently the Obama camp is spinning this as being inclusive despite having differences of opinion etc etc. Bullshit.
You want to spread a message of inclusiveness? I have an idea---how about letting the misogynistic bastards who have ruled organized religion for centuries be inclusive for a change? How about giving the stage to the Presiding Bishop of the Episcopal Church of the USA?
Pandering to bigots does not constitute inclusiveness, Mr. President-elect.
Update: For those who don't know, or think, that Rick Warren is a bigoted asshole, please check out Mike the Mad Biologist's piece and links therein.
/
Monday, December 15, 2008
The NFL is a rushing league
/
It is frequently said that success in the NFL is based on the ability to run the football on offense and to stop the run on defense. To those who follow the NFL this may be obvious. I was curious as to whether the numbers actually bore this out. So I went to the kick-ass website Pro-Football-Reference.com, took the rushing (for and against) stats for each team through week 14 and compiled the differential yards per game for all the teams. (At the time I did this, the Cleveland-Philly Wk14 game was not yet done---but the way the game looked in the third qtr it appears that its stats are going to be in line with our observations here).
Anyway, I compiled differentials for the passing stats too, and threw in (amongst a bunch of other stats) the won-loss record for good measure. Then I sorted the worksheet in different ways to see what, if anything, stood out. Well, one sort did stand out----the one sorted for rushing differential in descending order, and I have shown the table below.
| TEAM | RUSHING DIFFERENTIAL YARDS/GAME | PASSING DIFFERENTIAL YARDS/GAME | WIN--LOSS | |||||
| MINNESOTA VIKINGS | 76.4 | -25.5 | 9--5 | |||||
| BALTIMORE RAVENS | 63.7 | 7.2 | 9--5 | |||||
| NEW YORK GIANTS | 58.3 | 14.8 | 11--3 | |||||
| TENNESSEE TITANS | 49.4 | -0.1 | 12--2 | |||||
| NEW YORK JETS | 38.3 | -21.8 | 9--5 | |||||
| WASHINGTON REDSKINS | 36.1 | 24.7 | 7--7 | |||||
| CAROLINA PANTHERS | 34.6 | -0.6 | 11--3 | |||||
| NEW ENGLAND PATRIOTS | 29.2 | 28.8 | 9--5 | |||||
| ATLANTA FALCONS | 28.5 | 1.5 | 9--5 | |||||
| PITTSBURGH STEELERS | 20.3 | 42.4 | 11--3 | |||||
| MIAMI DOLPHINS | 17.4 | 17.5 | 9--5 | |||||
| DALLAS COWBOYS | 17.2 | 56.3 | 9--5 | |||||
| CHICAGO BEARS | 16.2 | -30.5 | 8--6 | |||||
| PHILADELPHIA EAGLES | 12.1 | 71.4 | 7--5--1 | |||||
| JACKSONVILLE JAGUARS | 0.1 | 17.6 | 5--9 | |||||
| BUFFALO BILLS | -0.2 | 9.5 | 6--8 | |||||
| TAMPA BAY BUCCANEERS | -1.2 | 51.9 | 9--5 | |||||
| SAN FRANCISCO 49ERS | -4.3 | 8.1 | 5--9 | |||||
| SAN DIEGO CHARGERS | -6.7 | 7.5 | 6--8 | |||||
| SEATTLE SEAHAWKS | -8.0 | -89.0 | 3--11 | |||||
| HOUSTON TEXANS | -8.9 | 65.4 | 7--7 | |||||
| NEW ORLEANS SAINTS | -11.3 | 82.5 | 7--7 | |||||
| DENVER BRONCOS | -26.5 | 43.1 | 8--6 | |||||
| GREEN BAY PACKERS | -29.0 | 42.0 | 5--9 | |||||
| ARIZONA CARDINALS | -33.6 | 99.6 | 8--6 | |||||
| KANSAS CITY CHIEFS | -40.7 | -38.6 | 2--12 | |||||
| CINCINNATI BENGALS | -44.5 | -40.3 | 2--11--1 | |||||
| CLEVELAND BROWNS | -48.4 | -35.2 | 4--9 | |||||
| OAKLAND RAIDERS | -48.8 | -34.0 | 3--11 | |||||
| INDIANAPOLIS COLTS | -52.3 | 46.0 | 10--4 | |||||
| ST. LOUIS RAMS | -58.0 | -33.2 | 2--12 | |||||
| DETROIT LIONS | -89.6 | -11.1 | 0--14 |
Pretty impressive correlation, huh? If you out-rush your opponent you are almost assured of having a winning record. The exceptions to this correlation are Washington (7&7; so at least they don‘t have a losing record) and Jacksonville (5&9). But Jacksonville has a positive differential of only 0.1 rush yard per game, so that is hardly a meaningful advantage and maybe their won-loss record isn‘t necessarily against the trend.
Also noteworthy--- Only four teams with a negative rush differential have winning records. They are Tampa Bay (9&5), Denver (8&6), Arizona (8&6) and Indianapolis (10&4). Of these, Denver and Arizona are the beneficiaries of playing in horrible divisions and thereby playing weak schedules. They do not fare well against good teams; indeed, in both cases, only two of their wins have come against opponents who have a winning record.
Indianapolis is a fascinating outlier. Looking at the stats one would try to explain their won-loss success with one or more of the following speculations:
1) Opponents are moving the ball really well against Indy but not scoring proportionately, i.e. the defense is keeping the team in games by not allowing TDs;
2) Indy is being very efficient with its drives;
3) Indy‘s offense is not doing very well, but shows up when it counts and manages to win close ballgames.
If you have followed the season so far, the above pretty much summarizes Indy’s season. The defense has allowed the third-fewest TDs in the league so far and has kept many games close; indeed, it has pretty much won 2 games for the team. And Peyton Manning has been responsible for some wins in other games by being absolutely clutch in the fourth quarter.
As for Tampa Bay---They had a really anomalous game that skewed their stats. A couple of weeks ago, Carolina ran for 299 yards against them. Now, 200-yd rushing games don't happen frequently and 300-yd rushing games are very rare in the NFL. If Tampa had only allowed a bad 200 as opposed to a horrible 299, they'd have a positive rushing differential (+5 yds/gm or so) for the season---more in keeping with their 9&5 record.
I guess my point is that wins and losses are decided by so many factors, and maybe every team has an anomalous game or two in some regard every season. Ultimately, the points scored vs points allowed decide the games, and important factors like turnovers, average field-position, red-zone offensive/defensive efficiency etc affect the outcome of every game. But given all this, one single stat---the rushing differential---is able to separate the good teams from the bad, for the most part.
All in all, interesting stuff. Run, and stop the run. Pretty simple, huh?
Update: Here's a follow-up article to this post.
/
Tuesday, December 9, 2008
Monday, December 8, 2008
More NFL musings
/
This was meant to be a general NFL post that started out with Steeler stuff, but then I saw Scribbler50’s latest Steeler-related comment (in my previous football post) while I was halfway through this one---so I’m just gonna make this a self-indulgent Steeler post and catch up with the rest of the stuff when I get time later this week.
One general comment: The NY Giants and the Tennessee Titans had strangleholds on the #1 playoff seed in their respective conferences. Now the strangleholds are merely decent grips.
Yesterday’s Cowboy-Steeler game was pivotal.
If the Steelers had lost the game they’d be in serious jeopardy of missing the playoffs (having to play Baltimore and Tennessee on the road the next two weeks). Now that they’ve won it, they have a shot at winning home field advantage throughout the playoffs.
The Steelers need to beat Baltimore (brutal assignment, but doable) to wrap up the division. If they then beat Tennessee, week 17 becomes really interesting---The 12-3 Steelers would play Cleveland at home while the 13-2 Titans would have to play the Colts in Indy. A Steeler win and a Titan loss would mean that the Steelers would be the #1 seed in the AFC. Could happen.
The Steelers aren’t going anywhere, however, if the O-line doesn’t get some of its shit together and if the Steelers don’t stick with the running game regardless. Pick a damn RB and feed him at least 20 carries a game---even behind great O-lines, RBs take 5-10 carries just to get their rhythm and figure out the D, the blocking and the speed. You can’t (like the Steelers did yesterday) have 12 running plays split between two RBs over three quarters, and then expect to successfully run it in when you get first and ten on the 8-yard line in the fourth qtr.
Further, defenses are sitting on the pass and they’re killing Ben Roethlisberger. I spent a few minutes on Pro-football-reference.com…..
This is Ben’s fifth year as a starter. In his first two seasons, the Steelers had Bettis and a power running game. They also had good O-line play. In those two seasons, Ben got sacked 30 and 23 times respectively.
The 2006 season was a bad one all around---Ben got into a stupid bike accident, they didn’t have Bettis---and Ben was sacked 46 times.
In 2007, there were major coaching changes--head coach, offensive coordinator, O-line coach---but the Steelers were good and Ben was a fucking stud. He got sacked 47 times, but managed a QB rating of 104.1, a completion percentage of 65.3% and threw 32 TDs vs. 11 INTs. (By comparison, Peyton Manning, who finished 2nd in MVP voting to Brady, was sacked only 21 times, had a QB rating of 98.0, a completion percentage of 65.4 and threw 31 TDs vs. 14 INTs). Anyway, I think this success, of the team and of Ben, masked a larger problem regarding the running game and the O-line. Throw in free agency and injuries and this year that problem is coming home to roost. Ben has been sacked 38 times in 13 games, has a QB rating of 80.1, and has thrown 14 TDs vs. 12 INTs. The Steelers average 3.6 yards per rush attempt this year whereas they averaged 4 yards or more per run in each of the previous four years. This is a merciless league---if teams figure out that your running game ain’t hurting anyone, they’ll tee off on your QB. And as my good friend (and erstwhile Giants fan) Tom once told me, “Its really hard to complete passes when you’re being bounced off the turf all the time”. Ugly as it looks, I think this is one of Ben’s finer seasons. The team is 10-3 largely because in key games Ben found a way to bring it home.
Bruce Arians’ play calling is horrible. Defenses are sitting on 1st down run, and 2nd and 3rd down passes. It is freaking pathetic. If the pass rush is constantly reaching your QB, try calling a screen pass, Bruce. Mewelde Moore may surprise the fuck out of you and take it to the house. Or just hand him the ball 12 times in the first half. And then on the third or fourth carry in the second half, he’ll take it to the house. It is really that simple, especially when you have a dominant defense backing you up. You are punting the shit out of the ball anyway---why not punt while wearing down the other line a bit and giving their D something to think about for a change? And next time you are inside the opponent's 5-yard line, humor me and go for a play action pass fade to the corner of the endzone to Hines Ward on first down. I mean, what have you got to lose? At this point, we expect you to turn it over on downs in such situations anyway.
It’s getting late so I have to stop with this thought---On the final Romo INT, Jason Witten slipped a bit, but Romo threw the ball high (like he’d done a couple of times previously in the game) though not really offline. All the experts were so caught up in whether Witten blew the route or Romo blew the throw that they forgot, I guess, to mention that Romo could see Lamarr freaking Woodley bust through the line right in front of him and flicked his throw a bit offbalance and sooner than he’d have liked to. So while Romo and Witten were falling all over themselves to take the blame, maybe someone should give a bit of credit to Woodley.
Actually, on second thought, don’t. Let him get madder and madder all week thinking about how they just wont give him credit. The Steelers could use some extra red-ass in Baltimore next week.
/
Sunday, December 7, 2008
Obama's Picks Lack Diversity, sorta---WashPo/MSNBC
/
From a Washington Post article featured on MSNBC.com:
(Excerpted, emphasis mine)
"While Obama's picks have been lauded for their ethnic and ideological mix, they lack diversity in one regard: They are almost exclusively products of the nation's elite institutions and generally share a more intellectual outlook than is often the norm in government."
Dammit, he is raising the intellectual bar in government by not hiring enough dumb, narrow-minded people like the "real Americans" who graduate from Regent and Liberty "Universities"!
/